Testing the A Class

More threads by Michel

Michel

The Prince of Arabia
Moderator
Messages
10,021
Points
775
Location
Sydney, Australia
As some of you might know, I test cars for the radio programme "The World on Wheels".
Lately we've had a few Benzes for trial and I thought you might like reading my son Albert's thought as relayed live on air in the 'Drive Of The Week' segment:

A compact hatchback, the A Class forms the entry point for Mercedes Benz’s model range and, as is typical with cars from the German manufacturer, it can be ordered in a number of different drivetrain and trim configurations.
A180-FrontMedium.jpg

But for my drive this week, my test car was the A180 CDI, the only diesel version of the A Class.
It’s powered by a 2.0 litre turbo diesel engine, producing 80 kilowatts of power and 250 Newton-metres of torque.
A180-BadgeMedium.jpg
A180-CDI-BadgeMedium.jpg

So why isn’t it called an A200 if it has a two litre engine? I think because the engine’s maximum power is equivalent to smaller petrol engines, thus A180 instead.
The engine mates to a six speed manual transmission or a continuously variable automatic, which Mercedes brands as ‘Autotronic’.
This is the first car I’ve encountered where a diesel engine is modulated by a CVT and I was impressed by the result.
A180-EngineMedium.jpg
A180-Engine-1Medium.jpg

Take-off speed is actually acceptable, even if you need to move straight away.
The CVT’s torque converter lets the engine rev high as you start moving, allowing the turbo to wind up for good performance off the mark.
The CVT is ultra smooth during driving, but quickly responds to kickdowns, bumping revs up almost immediately.
There’s also a virtual manual mode with seven set ratios for more control.
A180-Top-Medium.jpg

The A Class turns firmly around corners, although large bumps tend to unsettle the car.
The steering wheel is very light and easy to operate, making city parking a piece of cake.
The brakes are similarly easy to use, with a very sensitive pedal that bites firmly. Inside is a very roomy cabin, with enough leg room in the back to relax during long trips.

The cloth seat trim in my test car was very soft, while rear boot space is respectable, with the rear seats able to fold down to add more room.
There’s also plenty of storage pockets and drink holders throughout the car.
The A 180 CDI comes standard with climate control air conditioning, auto-on wipers and headlights, alloy wheels and front and rear foglamps.
There are plenty of option packages to add unique trim and other creature comforts, but the one I recommend is the Metro package, which adds the CVT gearbox, cruise control and front and rear parking assist.

A180-Dash-Medium.jpg
The A Class comes with the full safety complement of six airbags, ABS and electronic stability control.
The A180 CDI retails from $39,900 dollars, while the Metro Package is an extra $3600.
 

John S

New Member
Messages
636
Points
0
Location
Sydney
Michel, a friend mentioned last week that he was looking for an A Class, which got me thinking about your report here and my (poor) impression of the back seat ride quality, which I was not impressed with on the model 4 years ago.

Can you tell us if the rear seat ride on the latest models is of good quality, as 4 or so years ago I did not think it matched rivals of similar size, and they were very much cheaper at the time! The rest of the A Class was impressive though and the owner loved its speed and economy, plus the (front seat) ride.
 

BenzBoy

Grand Master
Messages
7,525
Points
705
Location
Sydney - Centre of Civilisation
John, I currently have a new A180 CDI as a service vehicle for several days and it is NOT the car my old A190 was. It lacks space and the versatile seating arrangement. Ride is not as good as it is in an A170 (go figure that) and in general I can't stand the clatter at idle, even though it revs to 4500rpm in a very silky manner. Rear seats are now different and not as comfortable. The car has regressed. While I would have given a big tick to the old A190 I have reservations about the new A180 for comfort and room. I am quite surprised. There is not even room enough for miss Olga's hatbox!!
Regards,
Benz-Boy
Edit - the dashboard in my A190 was leather covered. This one is hard plastic. Progress?
 
Last edited:

Styria

The Godfather
Moderator
Messages
9,382
Points
492
Location
Sydney
Hi everybody on this thread, great read, and very, very interestiong but also surprising comparisons. I have never driven one, so I find this all very interesting. Mind, I am puzzled and intrigued by Benz Boy's assessment which I highly respect.

Michel, thank you for posting this. I wish we could also have had the report on the B-Class as well which I rather like. Thanks guys, Styria
 

BenzBoy

Grand Master
Messages
7,525
Points
705
Location
Sydney - Centre of Civilisation
I think the answer is quite simple Mr S. When I bought my A190 in 2000 it was an expensive car but today the A Class is cheaper in both ticket prices and real money than it was 9 years ago. How do you make a car cheaper? You delete quality. I mean, this A180 has rear drum brakes and whereas in the A190 I could fit 4 show trollies standing upright, now I can fit 2. They are the same trollies.....
OK - it goes nicely but the quality has gone. The materials are cheaper and the space has been re-configured but it seems not effectively. I frankly can't recommend one and I find the exact same problems with the new ML which I had last month as a loan vehicle. You might ask why I seem to be having so many loan vehicles? Well, another story for another time. Let me put it this way: M-B is looking after the customer despite the ML warranty having expired years ago.
Regards,
Benz-Boy
 

Styria

The Godfather
Moderator
Messages
9,382
Points
492
Location
Sydney
Hi BenzBoy, again, very interesting ! You know, you read tests and assessments in various magazines, such as Mercedes Enthusiast, and you think 'well, looks as though they're getting their act together' especially as far as quality of interior furnishings and reliability are concerned.

I think it is fact that cars have come down in price over the last ten years, or that manufacturers are loading them up with goodies and technical improvements that at one stage you had to pay for. I would certainly be interested in details pertaining to your ML. Regards Styria
 

BenzBoy

Grand Master
Messages
7,525
Points
705
Location
Sydney - Centre of Civilisation
The ML story is simply one of an intermittent electrical fault which has shown up by locking the vehicle in Park, by then refusing to raise or lower windows and now by refusing to lock the tailgate. After an intitial diagnosis by MBS of certain faults in the fuseboxes and then later further faults in the wiring connectors, MBS has taken full repsonsibility for correcting these faults without charge and by supplying firstly an onsite mechanic to enable the gear slector and then a replacement vehicle without cost as they say the faults can be traced to original manufacturing or suppliers. I can not complain as the vehicle is a 2001 model and the warranty ran out in 2007. MBS has been most diligent in pursuing these faults and trying to ensure that there are no further ones. During the last 6 months I have had an interesting selection of MB cars to drive as replacement vehicles.
The service from MBS has been exemplary.
The only time the car has really failed was due to an independent failing to correctly secure the petrol line into the tank - the independent was not aware that there was a factory modification that was required.
Regards,
Benz-Boy
 
Similar threads
Thread starter Title Forum Replies Date
Styria Road Testing the A-Class Road Tests 5
Styria Testing the new s-class Talking Torque 5
c107 Carobu Engineering - 560 Dyno Testing Mercedes W126 30
motec 6.9 W116 crash testing Mercedes W116 0
Styria Testing K-Jet Injectors Technical Information 23
Michel Testing the 350SLK Talking Torque 2
c107 MBCNSW 50 years of the S-Class day Car Show Photos 6
H New S Class interior Interiors 3
S C Class for sale Gumtree/eBay/Facebook Listings 1
Styria S Class Mercedes - all ages Talking Torque 2
Styria Mercedes S-Class W140 Road Tests 2
Styria S-Class v. competitors Road Tests 1
Styria The S-Class Road Tests 0
S Class Action Technical Information 15
H New AA class Mercedes Websites and Links 2
S Boot Lid E Class 2003 Exteriors and Body Repairs 7
motec 6.9 C Class for Tim Talking Torque 5
260ebenz Excellent sales results- S-Class Articles 0
Styria S Class Interior Interiors 13
Styria 2014 CLS Class Road Tests 2
motec 6.9 New S Class Convertible Talking Torque 34
Styria 2015 S-Class S600 Road Tests 8
Styria 2012 A - Class Articles 0
260ebenz S-Class Coupe Articles 1
260ebenz Concept S-Class Coupe Road Tests 10
Styria S-Class Concept Interior Websites and Links 1
Styria Audi A8 vs. S - Class Road Tests 2
S A Class engines Mechanicals 4
Styria S-Class - ahead of its time. Road Tests 4
260ebenz S-Class History -Mercedes-Benz Luxury Sedans Road Tests 0
Styria 2014 S-Class Road Tests 1
Styria New S-Class Design Road Tests 0
260ebenz MB USA S-Class article Articles 1
260ebenz S-Class Coupe Road Tests 11
S A Class AMG Talking Torque 3
Styria 2013 - New S- Class Websites and Links 4
260ebenz W222 S-Class Articles 11
Styria Producing the C- Class Technical Information 0
Styria Mercedes 'S' class W140 Road Tests 1
Styria Mercedes - 'S' Class History Road Tests 1
6.9forever A-Class launch last night Talking Torque 23
Styria Origins of the s-class Talking Torque 2
Oversize New 2013 E-Class Talking Torque 8
Styria Links to W116 S-Class range Websites and Links 2
Styria The new B-Class Road Tests 2
motec 6.9 Mercedes Gold Class Cannes Articles 0
260ebenz Gold plated C-Class for sale Gumtree/eBay/Facebook Listings 16
Tony66_au W116 S-Class Sedan Documentary (English) Road Tests 3
Styria E-Class 63AMG Talking Torque 1
mathew The new-generation C-Class Talking Torque 1

Similar threads

Top